Book DetailsPaperback
Pages: 497
Publisher: Atom
Published: 2007
Language: English
ISBN: 978-1-904233-88-6
Book Review
I have to admit to not enjoying it as much as I did the first book. It took me quite awhile to get into it, but once I got into the second half I did get a lot more involved in the story (people did warn me this would happen). I suppose all of the books in the series will be similar; a big long build up where nothing much happens, leading to the climax with a bit of action.
My only other difficulty is the writing, I just don't think it's very good. I know, I know, who am I to judge? I couldn't write myself out of a paper bag if I needed to. Maybe it's just that in my mind I am comparing it to the Harry Potter series, which far outstrips the Twilight series in story and the quality of the writing (in my humble opinion). Perhaps it's just that the book is written for teenagers and I am used to reading for an older age group. There's just something about the writing that doesn't seem good to me.
The book had be laughing out loud - especially at the part where Edward proposes to Bella. That was hilarious. She is dying (pardon the pun) for Edward to turn her into a vampire so that they can be together for all eternity - but woh, hold your horses - marriage?! She's too young for that sort of commitment. I couldn't stop laughing as I read this bit.
Summary
What kind of read is this? Quick easy, young adult, paranormal.
Do I recommend it? Yes, for as much as I have problems with it, it is still a good read.
Do I recommend that you buy it? I do recommend buying it if you have the rest of the series. I don't know about you, but I am someone that particularly likes to own a series if I have actually read it.
Star Rating
This is tricky to rate. Although technically I don't have a system for rating half stars, I am going with 5.5 stars.
I will give it the 6 star comment "Really enjoyable and well written. I would recommend it", except I am removing the comment "well written", thereby awarding it only 5.5 stars.
6 comments:
I did not like this one at all. I liked the first book enough to read book 2, but I'll stop with this one. I skimmed over much of it because the writing was so horrible in places and Bella's clumsiness was driving me nuts.
I am totally with you, except that I will keep trying, everyone says it only gets better, and lets face it, that has to be true!
i shamelessly love this series, and new moon is not my favourite, eclipse is, in my opinion, the best in the series.
You are correct that the writing isn't the greatest. I liked book one because of the sexual tension between Bella and Edward and because I wanted to find out what would happen with the "bad" vampires. Book two took some time to get into and I found Bella to be incredibly annoying. Book three is definitely better but then comes book four. Ugh. I do own all four books in the series and they are entertaining. However I would recommend Beautiful Creatures instead. It is well written and romantic. It may be a big book but it is a page turner.
New Moon was my least favourite in the series. I did enjoy the series and I read them before all the hype. I agree, the writing isn't the greatest but I really enjoyed them. I considered them guilty pleasures. Everyone needs a guilty pleasure every now and then.
My daughters have all read the entire series, but I stopped after Twilight. I might rethink that choice, but I have so much on my tbr list.
Post a Comment
I love getting comments, so please don't hesitate to leave me one!